'Shaq' vs. 'Big Brother' -- Who won?

ABC premiered its new series "Shaq Vs." against three other original reality shows Tuesday evening and the basketball star mostly got whooped.

"Shaq Vs." drew 4.3 million viewers and a 1.7 preliminary adults 18-49 ratings, tying Fox's "More to Love" (4 million, 1.7) for third place in the oddly competitive 9 p.m. summer hour.

Flying into this buzzsaw, which included several competitors posting their best numbers all summer, ABC says they're pleased that "Shaq" managed to edge out "Love" in viewers and build 21% on its "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire" (6.3 million, 1.4) lead-in to post the network's best rating in this time period all summer. But this is about the same number that Shaq's previous short-lived ABC reality series ("Shaq's Big Challenge") received when it debuted on Tuesday last year.

Fox won the evening with "Hell's Kitchen" (7.3 million, 3.4) and "More to Love," both shows drawing their largest audience all summer, with "Love" up 8% in the demo.

NBC was right behind with a repeat and a two-hour "America's Got Talent" (11.6 million, 3.0).

CBS placed third with repeats and "Big Brother" (8.1 million, 2.9). "Brother" not only grew steeply once again, but also had its biggest demo rating since the show's 2007 season finale. It is now even in the demo compared to last year, with "The Bachelorette" being the only reality show to post a larger average audience this summer than last.

Leaving ABC fourth with "Millionaire," "Shaq Vs." and "Primetime" (3.5 million, 1.3).